Alabama’s redrawing of its congressional map defies US Supreme Court docket

Must read

Kim Chandler/AP

An Alabama Senate committee discusses a proposal to attract new congressional district traces on July 20, 2023, in Montgomery, Alabama.

A model of this story appeared in CNN’s What Issues e-newsletter. To get it in your inbox, join free right here.


It was a official shock when the conservative-dominated US Supreme Court docket ordered Alabama’s conservative-dominated state authorities final month to redraw its congressional map and embrace both a second majority-Black congressional district or one thing fairly near it.

It might be equally stunning that Alabama seems to have stated no.

As a substitute of merely complying with the Supreme Court docket’s order within the Allen v. Milligan case, Alabama’s legislature redrew the congressional map to decrease the Black voting-age inhabitants within the present Democratic seat held by Rep. Terri Sewell from about 55% to simply over 50% after which elevated a second district’s Black inhabitants proportion to about 40%.

The brand new map authorized by Alabama’s legislature and governor will go earlier than federal courts for evaluation in August, so this story is way from over.

And it’ll mix with fights over congressional maps in different states, particularly New York, in such a manner that management of the Home might very a lot be at stake.

Alabama Gov. Kay Ivey, a Republican, appeared to defend the legislature’s insolence within the face of the federal courts’ orders when it authorized the brand new map Friday.

“The Legislature is aware of our state, our folks and our districts higher than the federal courts or activist teams,” she stated in a press release.

CNN’s Dianne Gallagher famous in her report that the previous congressional map was invalidated by a three-judge federal district courtroom panel that included two judges nominated to the bench by former President Donald Trump.

They concluded the plan by which Alabamians chosen their congressional delegation in 2022 probably violated the Voting Rights Act as a result of Black voters have “much less alternative than different Alabamians to elect candidates of their option to Congress.”

Earlier than the 2022 midterm election, the US Supreme Court docket had tabled motion on Alabama’s map, which helped Republicans win the hardly there four-seat Home majority they at present maintain.

Gallagher and CNN’s Tierney Sneed wrote final month that the Allen v. Milligan resolution might have penalties for different states and reignite a sequence of lawsuits in a number of states.

“Outright defiance of the Supreme Court docket’s order,” is how Janai Nelson, president of the NAACP Authorized Protection Fund, described the brand new map to CNN’s Dana Bash Monday.

“On this second, it’s as much as our federal courts to guard Black voters and in addition to guard their very own authority right here,” she later added.

The background right here is that Alabama’s inhabitants is about 27% Black, however the Black inhabitants within the state is concentrated on plenty of counties which might be overwhelmingly African American – an space often called the state’s Black Belt, though it’s named for the world’s fertile soil. The curiosity of giving the voters of the Black Belt, a lot of whom are Black, illustration in Congress, is everywhere in the Supreme Court docket’s resolution.

Coincidentally, earlier this 12 months, President Joe Biden named Alabama’s Black Belt, website of many key moments within the Civil Rights Motion, as a Nationwide Heritage Space.

View this interactive content material on

To Nelson, the maths means that since Black Alabamians signify a few quarter of the state’s inhabitants, they need to get illustration from greater than one of many seven lawmakers representing Alabama in Congress.

However the subject is bigger than simple arithmetic since Alabama, each traditionally and at present, is marked by polarized voting circumstances.

“This can be a mandate by civil rights legal guidelines to make it possible for there’s equity in our techniques, that Black voters and different voters who’ve been traditionally discriminated in opposition to have a possibility to have representatives who will converse to their pursuits and provides voice to their issues,” she stated.

Alabama had requested the Supreme Court docket to basically nullify Part 2 of the Voting Rights Act, one thing many courtroom watchers thought the conservative majority was primed to execute.

However Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Brett Kavanaugh joined liberals on the courtroom to throw out the Alabama map.

The Supreme Court docket additionally rejected out of hand the concept that the Gulf Coast space represents a group of curiosity on par with the Black Belt. The brand new map, in response to the state legal professional normal’s workplace, nonetheless tries to maintain the Gulf Coast group collectively in a single district.

In a press release, the legal professional normal’s workplace argued the brand new map is honest and complies with the rules of the Voting Rights Act and seeks to unite the Black Belt counties.

The opposite political story right here is that, like most congressional districts nationwide, not one of the districts wherein Alabamians voted within the 2022 midterm elections was even comparatively aggressive. The one profitable candidate who bought lower than two-thirds of the vote was the Democrat, Sewell. And she or he nonetheless bought greater than 63% of the closely Democratic district.


- Advertisement -spot_img

More articles


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisement -spot_img

Latest article